hmmm, hearing a lot of silence here. Guess we know what points to press the technology folks on when bidding projects!

Question for all you RNG upgrading folks here, and facility operators who care to share:

What is your guaranteed % methane recovery at nameplate production levels? BUT, more importantly, what is your % recovery at lower flows, say at 50%, 75%, 90%, and 95% throughput?

Our experience with RNG upgrading plants in Canada and the USA, when operating…

Read more

Excellent point about the inoculum affecting the gas quality and quantity–that is one reason why we see full-scale food waste and SSO AD plants with own-growth biomass rarely match the results of a BMP study that uses a different inoculum, sometimes from a local domestic sewage digester and under ideal laboratory conditions.

I’ll go further…

Read more

Landfill gas is dramatically different from raw biogas produced inside engineered anaerobic digesters. In our experience across Canada and the United States we’ve seen raw landfill gas contain high percentages of air (+30% air), very high hydrogen sulfide from degrading construction waste, and VOCs from historical landfilling of paint and…

Read more

Since its inception more than 20 years ago, ADM1 has struggled with food waste and heterogeneous materials. Works reasonably well for nice homogenous sewage sludge. We’ve found the first‑order or Monod‑type hydrolysis kinetics, which assume 1) uniform particle accessibility, 2) constant surface area, and no physical disintegration limits…

Read more

Fugitive emissions monitoring around the mechanical plant is quite rare in our experience. We have some experience with state or federal EPA folks looking at US EPA Method 21 type monitoring and corresponding LDAR plans; though that is not very common.

Seen lots of discussion about residual methane potential of digestate in open…

Read more

What’s the frequency you suggest folks sample & test for the speciated VFA profiles to generate this information?

Well said Brad!

We are seeing digester owner clients dealing with issues of very poor turn-down on their upgraders, with more than 30% methane loss when operating at low flows. Dramatically poor performance from some upgrading technology as they wrestle with feedstock supply to be able to increase the production of raw biogas!

Oxygen in the liquid-phase is a non-starter. If there is oxygen then it is not anaerobic!

In the biogas phase, oxygen must be carefully considered. If there is any oxygen measured, was it added for a purpose or does it signal a leak to be investigated?

Of course, at high range is the fire and explosion risk.

A low level of oxygen is needed if…

Read more

ha ha ha, yes! The reality between academic study, a pretty spreadsheet, an state-of-the-art AI tool trained with sparse and poorly characterized data, and real world experience is huge. We’ve seen several pre-FEED or early-FEL projects get end up as disputes or expert witness situations because they developers wrongly relied on low quality data.…

Read more

Curious what benchmark or threshold total-VFA and / or total-LCFA concentrations values folks consider to be triggers for further investigation or action when operating their AD plants?

We’ve regularly compared spot-VFA estimates by titrations vs total and speciated VFA analysis via split testing. The field-expedient titration is only ever an estimate and the buffering chemistry involved, including ammonia and other pH-sensitive minerals, means if you’re looking for a strict VFA concentration, then you will likely be misled. …

Read more

Lots of good reasons for plug-flow, lots of good reasons for CSTRs too; same goes for high-rate, low-rate, temperature-phased, pH-phased, and the many other configurations available. In more than 30 years experience with AD systems of most sizes, shapes, and configurations, never seen a blanket declaration of ‘superior’ to be universally true…

Read more

well said Hatem, avoiding “…common industry practice of “blind supplementation,” which is costly and often unnecessary.” is a key feature of a well thought-out feeding plan and helps maximize the site’s business case.

Personally, I do pretty well on cheeseburgers and fries–but I’m not running in the Olympics either! Great digesters need great nutrition, macros, minerals, and trace metals too. In the AD sites we work with, most do not need any supplements. Some can get low cost cobalt, selenium, etc. from local animal nutrition and farming supply chains,…

Read more

In our experience we see different issues depending on the location. Could be 1) surprising amounts of glass or plastics, 2) paper that creates interesting mixing issues in wet AD, depending on local recycling initiatives, and 3) leaf and grass clippings waste that blinds up the screens on various types of depack units.