We’ve regularly compared spot-VFA estimates by titrations vs total and speciated VFA analysis via split testing. The field-expedient titration is only ever an estimate and the buffering chemistry involved, including ammonia and other pH-sensitive minerals, means if you’re looking for a strict VFA concentration, then you will likely be misled.
The good news is that it practice, it rarely matters. The rapid field test is enough to inform operators about their system’s stability. Instability can then be a trigger for more costly, slower, off-site lab testing for speciated VFAs.